Wake-Up Lights and Sunrise Simulators


Ok, so: sunrise simulators, dawn simulators, wake up lights, whatever you want to call them, help you wake up by slowly brightening a light over the course of 15-120 minutes, which syncs up your bodys natural circadian rythem. Supposedly you will wake up on your own, feeling refreshed and ready, rather than being woken up by your alarm. It is also claimed that you will be less groggy and more alert more quickly, and lastingly through the day. Then you will be more tired at night and better able to go to sleep. You can also get a Christmas light timer for less thn $5 at any hardware store and plug your lamp into it. However, this does not have the scientific research to show it is helpful, and it may actually be detrimental. I tried it with a full spectrum bulb and I can't say it's working.


 ( Here the red line shows how a normal alarm clock wakes you up. The yellow is sunlight waking, the green is a sunlight simulator (source: http://lightbox-for-sad.com/daybreak.html)
 

Factors to Consider

Light Quality:

Full spectrum lighting is the best, especially lights with a lot of the more blue end of the spectrum. Orange and red lights are good for going to sleep. A lot of sunrise simulators also have sunset modes where the light fades out instead of in. If you get a wake-up light that you plug your regular lamp into, I reccomend going to home depot and getting a good full spectrum light bulb for your lamp (less than $5). The "bluewave" stuff by Phillips seems to just output blue light only. That helps in SAD treatment, but I don't know if it is better for waking up. I decided I didn't want blue light.
 

Brightness:

Studies show that the effect works with about 250lux. I think almost all of them are about that. However, I have the feeling I'm going to need something brighter. I ended up going with the Sunrise System Lightbox (10,000lux). The bluemax version seems to be full spectrum, so I went with it. In looking at reviews online, many of them had people complaining about brightness. Perhaps these work best in situations where it really is dark outside, otherwise it won't make much of a difference. It is telling that these were originally designed to help treat SAD, which I doubt anyone below 50* Latitude ever gets, especially here in sunny Santa Barbara.
 

Complaints about quality:

Almost all of the products I saw had people complaining about how cheap and plasticy and poorly built they are. I guess you just expect more when you're spending $100+.
 

Good website resources:

http://www.truesun.com/products.php?cat=35
http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_ss_gw?url=search-alias%3Daps&field-keywords=dawn+simulator&x=0&y=0 (amazon seems to have everything)
http://bluemaxlighting.com/ (seems to take other products and put their own full spectrum lighting in them)
 

Quick Overview of a few Dawn Simulators

 

Sunrise Systems

http://www.morningsunrise.com/products.php
 [This is the one I ultimately chose to buy]

Sunrise System Lightbox $180 $170 amazon (bluemax $170)

"cheap quality"
    light:10,000lux, brightness adjustable.
    LCD backlight, adjustable brightness/contrast including "off"
    7 day alarm
    15-90 minute sunrise/sunset
    audio alarm
    power fail backup
 
 
 
(bluemax version: )

Sunrise System Dawn Simulator $130/$180 w/ mp3

    LCD backlight orange, adjustable
    Mp3 option
    7 day alarm
    15-90 minute sunrise/sunset
    light: 60W, E12&EU socket, brightness adjustable
    audio alarm
    power fail backup
 
 
 

Sunrise System Lamp Plug In $110

    Sunrise / Sunset 15-90 mins
    audio alarm increases in volume
    7 day alarm
    LCD backlight is adjustable / off
    up to 200 watt light: tungsten bulb only
    "snooze does not recur"
    "annoying to set"
    "light dims off again unless you press alarm button"
     powerfail backup
 

Philips (formerly Apollo Health)

http://lighttherapy.com/light_therapy_products.html
 
 

-goLITE BLU $280

    bluewave
 
 

-goLITE M2 $240

    bluewave
 
 

-goLITE P2 (Only at Costco)

    bluewave
 
 

-goLITE P1 $200

    bluewave
 
 
 

-briteLITE 6 $230

    10,000 lux, full spectrum
    15-60 mins
    for SAD treatment, not a wake up clock (though perhaps coudl be with a christmas light timer??)
 
 
 

-Daybreak Duo $200

 http://lighttherapy.com/daybreak.html
    Plug in lamp
    "s" curve intensifying
    LCD backlight automatically dims at night, amber, not blue/green, adjustable
    sunset mode
    weekend/weekday modes
    radio
    200Watts incandescent or "line-voltage halogen"


BioBrite

http://www.biobrite.com/products.php?category=SunRise%20Clocks
"low quality construction" "tedious to use, only 3 buttons" "
"60 watt, flame bulb in it"
"not bright enough"
  

Digital Sunrise Clock Charcoal $120 (no whitenoise)

    sunrise/sunset 15-90 min wake up time
    audio backup alarm
    LCD display brightness adjustable
 
 


Digital Sunrise Clock Pearl $125

    Charcoal plus whitenoise
 
 


Digital Sunrise Clock Radio $150

    charcoal plus radio

Soleil

http://www.soleilsunalarm.com/

 

Soleil Sun Alarm $90

    "96 lumens" "krypton bulb"  "not bright enough" "TINY! very very small."
    radio
    optional plug in lamp addon 300watt $40 (nice!)
    15-120 min wakeup cycle

Verilux

http://www.verilux.com/light-therapy-lamps/sleeping-waking-light


 Rise & Shine $150

    full spectrum
    sunset/sunrise 5-60 mins
    dim the bulb
    "display is too bright"
    "lamp hums"
    "sound is terrible quality"
    "poor quality"
    "initial light on is very bright"
    "buzzing sounds"

Sunrise Creator

 http://www.sunrisecreator.com/



Sunrise Creator $85

   very simple, not many features

Hammacher Schlemmer

http://www.hammacher.com/publish/70460.asp


Peaceful Progression Wake Up Clock $50

    "not very progressive--light comes on too quickly"
    some models also do fancy sound/aroma release
 

Other Thoughts


REM tracking alarms:

There are alarms that monitor your REM cycles and wake you up in a certain timeframe/window.

Non-American:

 

Emailed Suggestions

 
---
There is one that is really good sold in the Skymall magazine. Go to skymall.com and will find it. It starts with aromatherapy, then lights, then buzzer at end of cycle if person not wake with the other two.  [Peaceful Progression Wake Up Clock]

---

My mother has used a wake up light for years.  I am from Washington state so it is really helpful to have something like this.  I believe the one she bought was from sharper image, but if memory serves they are now out of business.  I would definitely recommend them (I am thinking of getting one myself). 

---
 
You might also try verilux.com to see what they have.  I have one of their full-spectrum lights on my desk.
 
---
 
My old house was furnished with built in "wake-up" light pillars that were in every room (from the floor to the ceiling) they did work perfectly but were much larger in size. It is a great idea, but I cant imagine using small ones like the one in the video. I would think after time you would get used to it? I grew up in Thailand so mine too were overseas.
 
---
 
I use an alarm from Brookstone that wakes me up with light and nature sounds.  I couldn't find the exact model online since I've had it for a few years, but you might want to check this one out:
http://www.brookstone.com/store/product.asp?product_code=daybreak_alarm_clock&search_type=search&search_words=alarm%20clock&prodtemp=t1&cm_re=Result*R4C1*T
 
---
 
You may find some good info on types of lights here
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seasonal_affective_disorder
 
---
 
or you could try the bed shaker http://unitedtty.com/store/product133.html
 
---
 
I'm guessing that you don't have children (since you probably wouldn't have much use for a wakeup light when your kids will happily wake you up at 6:30... atleast that's the case in my home).
I recall seeing one in a catalog years ago.... not sure if was Sharper Image or Brookstone or something like that.  Sorry, can't be of more help.
 
---
 
I had a wake up light when I lived in England.
There are too many other contributing factors to pinpoint anything, but the first year I was there, and did not have the light, I got SAD. subsequent years, I did not.
 
I really enjoyed the slow light progression in the morning, because I hate alarm clocks. It would start out very dim and slowly get brighter over half an hour, and I would wake up naturally, even though it was still dark outside in the winter time at 9 am. If the light didn't wake me up on my own, there's a gentle beep of an alarm, nothing like the heart attack inducing alarms I normally avoid. And vice versa in the evening, it would get progressively dimmer until it shut off.
 
I would have loved to bring my clock back to the US, but the electrical systems aren't not compatible, and a converter just does not work with clocks. the slightest thing off, and the timing starts losing seconds here and there, so as a timepiece, it was no longer effective. Other electical items can transfer over okay, but clocks...they're either accurate or they aren't, nothing to compromise inbetween.
 
I think a backup battery would help in other situations, but am unsure whether it would have any effect on the actual accuracy of the clock overall. Satellite accuracy, yes, that would solve the problem! But the battery sounds like a backup, and that won't matter if the clock itself thinks it's operating normally.
The voltage doesn't need to effect the timing much to make the point of the clock moot, it's a timepiece and it needs to keep the time. :)
I debated this a lot with folks there, trust me, I wanted to bring the clock back with me. But once I acknoweldged that the point of the clock was to dependably give the right time, I was resigned. Even being off a second a day should be unacceptable, but the friends who've brought clocks trans-atlantic report that they would be off about 5 minutes day.
 
---
 
Hi Brenton, I suggest one of these two fine products from thinkgeek
http://www.thinkgeek.com/homeoffice/lights/91f2/
http://www.thinkgeek.com/homeoffice/lights/8f1a/
 
---
 
I was living in the UK last winter and seriously considered buying one of these lamps. Our dark mornings in the U.S. are nothing compared to England's! The prices are fairly expensive (so will be shipping from the UK). If you want to put something to work straight away, you're probably best off buying a comparable fixture from the U.S. Here are a couple quick links to available clocks in the U.S.
 
This one seems a bit fancy: http://www.hammacher.com/publish/70460.asp?source=google&keyword=wake+up+clocks&cm_ven=NewGate&cm_cat=google&cm_pla=TopProducts&cm_ite=wake+up+clocks&OVMTC=Broad&site=&creative=1089714861&OVKEY=wake%20up%20clocks
 
But here are a few others to look at : http://www.gadgetshack.com/light-therapy-sun-alarm-clock.html [Sunrise Alarm, Daybreak Duo, GoLITE M2]
 
---
Amazon has a handful: http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_ss_gw?url=search-alias%3Daps&field-keywords=wake+up+light&x=0&y=0


There's quite a few more under "Customers Who Viewed This Item Also Viewed" as well, my search for "wake up light" might not have been the best keywords to use

---
 
I actually have this unit for overall sleep therapy:
http://naturebright.com/sunTouchPlus.php?gclid=CJzrjqiw65YCFRNOagodtDigOQ
I also have an alarm clock from the Sharper Image which can be set up to wake with light.
 
---
 
My wife bought this one a couple of weeks ago:
http://www.amazon.com/Verilux-Shine-Natural-Deluxe-Bedside/dp/B000F97B6M [Verilux Rise and Shine]
My complaint with it is that the display is too bright - I hate any type of light source at night, and this isn't easily covered up with some pjs, like with a normal alarm clock. It's plenty bright to wake me up in the morning, and I really do enjoy the way it slowly wakes me up. It's a sufficient light source for reading in the bedroom at night.
 
---
[Daybreak Duo] [Peaceful Progression Wake Up] 
That's it folks!
 
-Brenton